Đang tải... (xem toàn văn)
International Management Navigating Cultural Differences A Case Study of Ford Vietnam
International Management Navigating Cultural Differences: A Case Study of Ford Vietnam DUC THANG, TRAN Word count: 2316 Contents Introduction 1.1 Executive Review 1.2 Main Issues 1.3 Theory/Concepts Used: Findings 2.1 Differences in Power Distance: .2 2.2 Differences in Individualism: 2.3 Communication Barriers 2.4 Differences in Time Orientation: Discussion 3.1 Summarize 3.2 Alternative Solutions 3.2.1 Cross-Cultural Training 3.2.2 Cross-Cultural Communication Strategies .5 3.2.3 Diversify the Workforce Conclusion Recommendation References Introduction 1.1 Executive Review The objective of this case study is to scrutinize the intricacies of cross-cultural management faced by Ford Motor Company during its operations in Vietnam To achieve this aim, the study endeavours to discern the primary cultural disparities that arise when an American company such as Ford operates as a subsidiary in Vietnam, utilizing theoretical frameworks and models of Hofstede, Meyer, and Lewis Drawing on these cultural distinctions, the study seeks to shed light on the principal challenges in cross-cultural management that Ford encountered in Vietnam and proffer alternative solutions to overcome them Furthermore, the study proposes potential remedies for prospective issues that may arise within the company and recommends the most suitable solution, which is to provide cross-cultural training 1.2 Main Issues Conflicts arising from differences in power distance Misunderstandings of differences between individualism and collectivism Communication barriers resulting from differences in context Issues with time management and scheduling due to differences in time orientation 1.3 Theory/Concepts Used: The essay draws upon several theories and concepts to explain the cultural differences between Vietnamese employees and American managers from Ford Motor Company These include Hofstede's cultural dimensions theory, which emphasizes the differences in power distance and individualism between the two cultures (Hofstede Insights, 2017) Meyer's cultural dimensions theory is also used to describe the differences in communication style and time orientation (Meyer, 2014) Besides, The Lewis Cultural Model categorizes cultures into polychronic and monochronic cultures based on their approach to time (Lewis, 1997) Findings 2.1 Differences in Power Distance: As per Hofstede's cultural dimensions theory, the power distance index (PDI) is a crucial aspect of cross-cultural communication, especially in the workplace (Sorge & Hofstede, 1983) In Vietnam, the high PDI indicates a greater acceptance of hierarchical structures and a strong emphasis on status and rank (Hofstede Insights, 2023) This can lead to differences in behaviour between Vietnamese employees and managers from other cultural backgrounds, who may not be used to such deference and respect towards authority (Organizational Psychology Degrees, 2022; Corporate Finance Institute, 2023) For instance, if American managers from Ford, with a relatively low PDI, were to work with Vietnamese employees, they may find it challenging to navigate the hierarchical structure of the Vietnamese workplace culture (Khatri, 2009) Consequently, this could lead to communication gaps and conflicts in the workplace 2.2 Differences in Individualism: According to Hofstede's theory, Vietnam has a collectivistic culture, where group harmony and consensus are valued more than individual interests (Hofstede Insights, 2017) “Ford Motor Company”, in contrast, has a more individualistic culture that places a higher value on personal success and recognition (Hofstede Insights, 2023) Particularly in the decision-making and goal-setting processes, these cultural differences can cause misunderstandings and disputes between American managers and Vietnamese personnel (Yates & De Oliveira, 2016) For instance, American managers can favour making decisions based on individual contributions and accomplishments, but Vietnamese workers might put more emphasis on group harmony and consensus The two groups may get frustrated and at odds as a result of this (Borton & Ryder, 2000) Additionally, American managers could be more inclined to give workers individual goals, but Vietnamese workers might feel more at ease with team-oriented objectives This can lead to conflict and miscommunication between American managers who value individual success and Vietnamese workers who value collective cohesion (Indeed Editorial Team, 2022a) 2.3 Communication Barriers In any organization, interpersonal communication is essential, but it's especially important when working across cultures (Thrive Qube, 2021) Meyer's cultural dimensions theory highlights the importance of understanding cultural differences in communication style (Meyer, 2016) Vietnam is categorized as a high-context culture, where communication is often implicit and relies heavily on nonverbal cues and context This means that Vietnamese people tend to communicate indirectly and rely on shared cultural knowledge and understanding to convey their message (Manuel, 2019) On the other hand, Ford Motor Company, being a low-context culture, emphasizes explicit and direct communication American managers from Ford may be more likely to state their message clearly and directly without relying on nonverbal cues or shared cultural understanding (Van Vliet, 2023) These differences in communication style can create barriers and misunderstandings in crosscultural communication For example, an American manager may give direct feedback to a Vietnamese employee, which may be perceived as confrontational or disrespectful in the high-context Vietnamese culture Similarly, a Vietnamese employee may use nonverbal cues or indirect language to convey a message to their American manager, which may not be understood or interpreted correctly (Athiya, 2023; Varadanin, 2023) 2.4 Differences in Time Orientation: The significant distinctions between Vietnamese employees and Ford Motor Company overseas managers in terms of how they perceive time are highlighted by Meyer's theory of cultural dimensions (Meyer, 2014) Time is seen as more flexible and less organized in Vietnam because of its polychronic culture This suggests that Vietnamese workers are more prone to multitask and value interpersonal relationships as a key component of work activities In contrast, the Ford Motor Company operates in a monochronic culture that sees time as a limited resource that must be organized and handled effectively Because of this, American managers tend to focus on one task at a time and prioritize meeting deadlines over building relationships with employees (Bartleby, 2021; Project Practical, 2021; Indeed Editorial Team, 2022b; Robby, 2022) Differences in timeliness and time management, as well as misunderstandings and difficulties in fulfilling deadlines and scheduling, may result from the conflicting views of time between Vietnam and Ford Motor Company Vietnamese workers might regard deadlines as being more pliable and less rigorously regulated, which would cause them to value relationships more than the prompt delivery of deliverables However, American managers can view this as a sign of a lack of dedication and professionalism, which could create issues with scheduling and fulfilling deadlines Differences in timeliness and time management may sometimes lead to workplace conflict For example, American bosses could perceive tardiness as a sign of contempt and unprofessionalism while Vietnamese employees might not consider punctuality to be a crucial component of business meetings In summary, the different ways that Vietnam and Ford Motor Company perceive time can cause issues with deadlines and scheduling as well as disparities in timeliness and time management (Pant, 2016) Discussion 3.1 Summarize Differences in Power Distance: Vietnam has a high-power distance culture where hierarchy and status are respected This can clash with Ford's low power distance culture where authority is more challenged This can lead to communication issues and conflicts between Vietnamese employees and American managers (Hofstede Insights, 2023) Differences in Individualism: Vietnam has a collectivistic culture that values group harmony while Ford has an individualistic culture that values personal success This can cause misunderstandings in decision-making, goal-setting, and workplace behaviours between the two groups (Hofstede Insights, 2023) Communication Barriers: Vietnam is a high-context culture that relies on implicit communication and nonverbal cues Ford is a low-context culture that values direct and explicit communication This can lead to misunderstandings and ineffective communication between American managers and Vietnamese employees (Manuel, 2019; Van Vliet, 2023) Differences in Time Orientation: Vietnam has a polychronic culture that sees time as flexible and values relationships Ford has a monochronic culture that sees time as limited and values efficiency This can cause issues with meeting deadlines, timeliness, and scheduling between the two groups (Pant, 2016) 3.2 Alternative Solutions 3.2.1 Cross-Cultural Training One solution to addressing the identified problems is to provide cultural training to both American managers and Vietnamese employees A variety of approaches, including coaching sessions, online courses, and live seminars, can be used to give cultural training It is an adaptable solution that can be tailored to the requirements of the business and its staff Additionally, cultural training is not an approach that can be applied to everyone; instead, it calls for thorough consideration of the organization's unique difficulties and its particular cultural environment (Hahn, 2021) Advantages: Cultural training may improve intercultural sensitivity and understanding, which can improve collaboration, productivity, and communication Additionally, it can contribute to fostering a more welcoming and varied workplace culture, which will enhance worker satisfaction and retention (Chebium, 2015; Indeed Editorial Team, 2023) Disadvantages: In particular, if it is done for a large number of employees, cultural training may be time-consuming and expensive Measuring a training program's success and its effects on intercultural cooperation and communication can be difficult Additionally, some workers might not find cultural training interesting or may not think it applies to the duties of their position (Chebium, 2015; Traliant, 2018) 3.2.2 Cross-Cultural Communication Strategies Another solution is to implement cross-cultural communication strategies that can help bridge the differences in power distance, individualism, communication style, and time orientation For example, American managers can learn to be more indirect in their communication style and pay attention to nonverbal cues Vietnamese employees can learn to express their opinions and ideas more directly and explicitly (Xu & Wang, 2021; Wang & Wuhong, 2021; Kuesoongnern, 2018) Advantages: In addition to fostering respect and understanding amongst people, it can assist reduce misunderstandings and confrontations Additionally, they can foster a more favourable work climate and increase cross-cultural collaboration and productivity (Hall, 2021) Disadvantages: Implementing and maintaining this strategy can be difficult, particularly certain if Additionally, some workers workers show could find reluctance it or lack challenging to commitment modify their communication style or adjust to new standards and expectations Additionally, time-consuming, cross-cultural communication tactics demand ongoing evaluation and modification (Hall, 2021; Best Colleges Online, 2021) 3.2.3 Diversify the Workforce The third option is to increase the number of Vietnamese workers or promote them to managerial positions to diversify the workforce This approach may contribute to a more inclusive and varied work environment by increasing the representation of Vietnamese culture and values in the workplace (World Bank Group, 2013; Vietnam Investment Review, 2021) A more balanced decisionmaking process may be achieved by adding more Vietnamese managers to assist overcome the differences in power distance, communication style, and time orientation (Waldman, 2021) Advantages: It can enhance intercultural communication and collaboration and foster a more welcoming and varied workplace Additionally, it may improve the company's standing for inclusion and diversity while boosting employee happiness and retention (Winstead, 2022; Rosew, 2021) Disadvantages: It could be difficult, particularly if there are not enough Vietnamese candidates who meet the requirements The recruiting or promotion process may be viewed as prejudiced or unjust by current employees, who may become resistant or tense Additionally, a more diverse workforce could not fully solve all cultural differences and difficulties in cross-cultural cooperation (Reynolds, 2022; Vaughan, 2021) Conclusion It is essential to understand the cultural differences between two groups to manage cross-cultural teams effectively Providing cultural training is an excellent solution to address the identified problems It's important to note that cultural training should be a two-way process to ensure that both American managers and Vietnamese employees understand each other's cultural differences and expectations (Penn LPS, 2020) In conjunction with cultural training, proactively endorsing diversity and inclusivity in the workplace represents an alternative resolution to proficiently manage cross-cultural teams Enterprises may foster an environment that encourages personnel from varying cultural backgrounds to operate together as diverse teams This approach can promote cultural awareness and sensitivity, mitigate instances of misunderstanding and discord, and amplify ingenuity and originality Moreover, a diverse leadership team can further advance inclusivity and comprehension By appointing leaders from diverse cultural lineages, the enterprise can ensure that all employees are esteemed and heard, and cultural differences are acknowledged (O’Donoghue, 2023; Tomar, 2019) Ultimately, maintaining transparent communication channels is fundamental in addressing any cultural misunderstandings or conflicts Regular feedback sessions, team-building activities, and cultural events can engender a favourable and inclusive workplace, where employees can express their opinions and concerns without reservation (Markman, 2021) Recommendation Based on the evaluation of alternative solutions, the recommended solution is to provide cross-cultural training to both American managers and Vietnamese employees This solution addresses all four problems identified, namely differences in power distance, individualism, communication barriers, and time orientation By providing cross-cultural training, American managers will gain a better understanding of Vietnamese culture and the impact of power distance, collectivism, high-context communication, and polychronic time in the workplace Similarly, Vietnamese employees will learn about American culture and the importance of low power distance, individualism, low-context communication, and monochronic time in the workplace (Bross et al., 2000; Tanneau & McLoughlin, 2021) It should be thorough and address a variety of cultural variations, including beliefs, attitudes, communication methods, work ethics, and decision-making procedures Besides, it should also incorporate experiential learning activities like role-playing, simulations, and case studies to help participants understand the practical impacts of cultural differences at work (Tanneau & McLoughlin, 2021) The following tactics should be used to guarantee the cross-cultural training program's effectiveness: Needs assessment: To determine the precise cultural differences that are generating problems in the workplace, a requirements assessment should be carried out before constructing the training program (Learnit, 2022) Customization: To specifically address the demands of the American management and Vietnamese staff, the training program should be customized The content should be delivered in a way that respects the learning styles and cultural backgrounds of the participants (Kiet, 2022; Glowacka, 2022) Follow-up: Following the training, subsequent meetings should be held to assess the training's success and resolve any lingering cultural obstacles This may be accomplished through coaching, mentoring, and feedback surveys (Beus, 2016; Tanneau & McLoughlin, 2021) Integration: Ford Motor Company's regular training and development programs should incorporate the cross-cultural training program to make sure that new hires receive it and that it is regularly updated (Chebium, 2015) A group of qualified trainers with experience working in both American and Vietnamese cultures and cross-cultural communication expertise should lead the cross-cultural training program To ensure that both viewpoints are included in the training, the team should include both American and Vietnamese trainers The ability of the trainers to facilitate experiential learning activities should be considered along with their cultural sensitivity and communication skills References Athiya (2023) The difference in communication styles between highcontext and low-context cultures www.linkedin.com Retrieved April 16, 2023, from https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/differencecommunication-styles-between-high-context-cultures/ Bartleby (2021) Vietnamese vs American Styles Retrieved April 12, 2023, from https://www.bartleby.com/essay/Vietnamese-vsAmerican-Styles-PK2TUNL36YYS#:~:text=Edward%20Hall %20classifies%20time%20systems,as%20other%20low%2Dcontext %20cultures Best Colleges Online (2021, May 18) How Can I Foster a Culture of Respect Within my Organization? - Best Colleges Online Retrieved 10 April 18, 2023, from https://www.bestcollegesonline.org/faq/howcan-i-foster-a-culture-of-respect-within-my-organization/ Beus, B (2016, November 21) Evaluate & follow up: post-training best practices HRZone Retrieved April 20, 2023, from https://www.hrzone.com/community/blogs/blakebeus/evaluatefollow-up-post-training-best-practices Borton, Lady, & Ryder, P (2000) Working in a Vietnamese voice Academy of Management Perspectives, 14(4), 20–29 https://doi.org/10.5465/ame.2000.3979813 Bross, A., Churchill, A., & Zifkin, J (2000, June 5) Cross-cultural training: Issues to consider during implementation Canadian HR Reporter Retrieved April 19, 2023, from https://www.hrreporter.com/news/hr-news/cross-cultural-trainingissues-to-consider-during-implementation/308520 Chebium, R (2015, January 7) How to Create an Effective Cross-Cultural Training Program SHRM; SHRM Retrieved April 18, 2023, from https://www.shrm.org/hr-today/news/hr-magazine/Pages/010215cross-cultural-training.aspx Corporate Finance Institute (2023, March 13) Hofstede’s Cultural Dimensions Theory Retrieved April 7, 2023, from https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/management/hofst edes-cultural-dimensions-theory/ Glowacka, M (2022, December 22) Cross-cultural management & 10 expert ways to improve your skills Language Learning With Preply Blog Retrieved April 20, 2023, from 11 https://preply.com/en/blog/b2b-10-ways-cross-culturalmanagement-workplace/ Hahn, M (2021, January 21) considerations for cultural training — Hahn Cultural Consulting Hahn Cultural Consulting Retrieved April 18, 2023, from http://www.hahncultural.com/insights/culturaltrainingconsideration s Hall, J (2021, April 18) Ways To Promote Respect In The Workplace Forbes Retrieved April 18, 2023, from https://www.forbes.com/sites/johnhall/2021/04/18/5-ways-topromote-respect-in-the-workplace/?sh=754d7cad7fe2 Hofstede Insights (2017, August 22) Vietnam - Hofstede Insights Retrieved April 24, 2023, from https://www.hofstede-insights.com/country/vietnam/ Hofstede Insights (2023b, January 27) Country Comparison - Hofstede Insights Retrieved April 6, 2023, from https://www.hofstedeinsights.com/country-comparison/the-usa,vietnam/ Indeed Editorial Team (2022a, June 24) Individualist vs Collectivist Workplace Cultures: How They Differ Indeed Career Guide Retrieved April 7, 2023, from https://www.indeed.com/careeradvice/career-development/individualism-vs-collectivist-workplaceculture Indeed Editorial Team (2022b, June 25) Monochronic vs Polychronic Time: Cultural Differences in Time Management Indeed Career Guide Retrieved April 17, 2023, from 12 https://www.indeed.com/career-advice/career-development/polychr onic-time Indeed Editorial Team (2023, February 4) What Is Cultural Competence and Why Is It Important? Indeed Career Guide Retrieved April 18, 2023, from https://www.indeed.com/career-advice/careerdevelopment/cultural-competence Khatri, N (2009) Consequences of Power Distance Orientation in Organisations Vision: The Journal of Business Perspective, 13(1), 1–9 https://doi.org/10.1177/097226290901300101 Kiet, A (2022, January 10) Vietnam’s strategy to enhance vocational education and training until 2030 hanoitimes.vn Retrieved April 20, 2023, from https://hanoitimes.vn/vietnams-strategy-to-enhancevocational-education-and-training-until-2030-319701.html Kuesoongnern, S (2018, July 1) Cross–cultural communication in Thai EFL university classrooms: a case study UOBREP Retrieved April 18, 2023, from https://uobrep.openrepository.com/handle/10547/623307 Learnit (2022, March 3) Cross-Cultural Training and its Importance in The Global Workforce Retrieved April 20, 2023, from https://www.learnit.com/blog/cross-cultural-training-and-itsimportance-in-the-global-workforce Lewis, R J (1997) When cultures collide: Managing successfully across cultures Long Range Planning, 30(3), 469 https://doi.org/10.1016/ s0024-6301(97)80938-7 13 Manuel (2019, December 27) Improving communication in Vietnamese intercultural teams - Culture Bridge Culture Bridge Retrieved April 7, 2023, from https://culturebridge.asia/communicationtraining/ Markman, A (2021, September 10) Ways to Identify Cultural Differences on a Global Team Harvard Business Review Retrieved April 19, 2023, from https://hbr.org/2018/06/3-ways-to-identifycultural-differences-on-a-global-team Meyer, E (2014) The Culture Map: Breaking Through the Invisible Boundaries of Global Business Meyer, E (2016) Mapping out Cultural Differences on Teams Erin Meyer Retrieved April 7, 2023, from https://erinmeyer.com/mapping-out-cultural-differences-on-teams/ O’Donoghue, D (2023, March 1) What Is Cross-cultural Communication and Why It Matters G2 Retrieved April 19, 2023, from https://www.g2.com/articles/what-is-cross-cultural-communication Organizational Psychology Degrees (2022, August 26) Power Distance: Definition and Examples - Organizational Psychology Degrees https://www.organizationalpsychologydegrees.com/faq/what-ispower-distance/ Pant, B (2016, May 23) Different Cultures See Deadlines Differently Harvard Business Review Retrieved April 14, 2023, from https://hbr.org/2016/05/different-cultures-see-deadlines-differently Penn LPS (2020, October 29) Why cross-cultural communication is important | Penn LPS Online Penn LPS Online Retrieved April 19, 14 2023, from https://lpsonline.sas.upenn.edu/features/why-crosscultural-communication-important-and-how-practice-it-effectively Project Practical (2021, March 28) Monochronic vs Polychronic Cultures: Differences, Examples ProjectPractical.com Retrieved April 17, 2023, from https://www.projectpractical.com/monochronic-vs-polychronic/ Reynolds, K (2022, August 5) 13 benefits and challenges of cultural diversity in the workplace Hult International Business School Retrieved April 18, 2023, from https://www.hult.edu/blog/benefitschallenges-cultural-diversity-workplace/ Robby (2022, December 24) Monochronic vs Polychronic Time: Cultural Differences in Time Management - support your career Support Your Career Retrieved April 17, 2023, from https://yourcareersupport.com/polychronic-time/ Rosew (2021, November 5) The Advantages of Intercultural Communication The Classroom | Empowering Students in Their College Journey Retrieved April 18, 2023, from https://www.theclassroom.com/advantages-interculturalcommunication-12066503.html Sorge, A., & Hofstede, G (1983) Culture’s Consequences: International Differences in Work-Related Values Administrative Science Quarterly, 28(4), 625 https://doi.org/10.2307/2393017 Tanneau, C., & McLoughlin, L (2021, June 22) Effective Global Leaders Need to Be Culturally Competent - SPONSOR CONTENT FROM THE INTERNATIONAL COACHING FEDERATION Harvard 15 Business Review Retrieved April 19, 2023, from https://hbr.org/sponsored/2021/06/effective-global-leaders-need-tobe-culturally-competent Thrive Qube (2021, February 12) Communicating Across Cultures ThriveQube.com Retrieved April 7, 2023, from https://thriveqube.com/workshops/communicating-across-cultures/ Tomar, B (2019, April 23) The Importance Of Cross-Cultural Management Forbes Retrieved April 19, 2023, from https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbeslacouncil/2019/04/23/theimportance-of-cross-cultural-management/?sh=28b70291b5c3 Traliant (2018, July 25) Reasons Cultural Diversity & Sensitivity Training Is Important | Traliant Retrieved April 18, 2023, from https://www.traliant.com/blog/5-reasons-cultural-sensitivitytraining-is-important/ Van Vliet, R (2023, April 3) Leadership and communication in global cross-cultural teams Lepaya Retrieved April 7, 2023, from https://lepaya.com/en/leadership-and-communication-in-globalcross-cultural-teams/ Varadanin, O (2023, January 18) What are the differences between high context and low context cultures? Country Navigator Retrieved April 17, 2023, from https://www.countrynavigator.com/blog/whatare-the-differences-between-high-context-and-low-context-cultures/ Vaughan, T (2021, August 12) Importance of intercultural communication in an organisation Poppulo Retrieved April 18, 16 2023, from https://www.poppulo.com/blog/importance-ofintercultural-communication-in-an-organisation Vietnam Investment Review (2021, April 21) Challenges women face and advantages they bring to the Vietnamese workplace Vietnam Investment Review - VIR Retrieved April 18, 2023, from https://vir.com.vn/challenges-women-face-and-advantages-theybring-to-the-vietnamese-workplace-83771.html Waldman, E (2021, October 11) How to Manage a Multi-Generational Team Harvard Business Review Retrieved April 18, 2023, from https://hbr.org/2021/08/how-to-manage-a-multi-generational-team Wang, Y., & Wuhong, C (2021) Cross-cultural Communication Strategies Research of Socializing Apps During Internet Era In Advances in social science, education and humanities research Atlantis Press https://doi.org/10.2991/assehr.k.210806.084 Winstead, A (2022, August 1) The Importance of Intercultural Communication in Today’s Workplace Worth Retrieved April 18, 2023, from https://www.worth.com/the-importance-of-interculturalcommunication-in-todays-workplace/ World Bank Group (2013, December 2) Vietnam Development Report 2014 - Skilling up Vietnam: Preparing the workforce for a modern market economy World Bank; The World Bank Retrieved April 18, 2023, from https://www.worldbank.org/en/country/vietnam/publication/vietnam -development-report2014-skilling-up-vietnam-preparing-theworkforce-for-a-modern-market-economy 17 Xu, Q., & Wang, G.-M (2021, May 6) Cross-Cultural Communication of Regional Images Based on Multimodal Discourse Analysis and Network Security Mobile Information Systems Retrieved April 18, 2023, from https://downloads.hindawi.com/journals/misy/2021/9956593.pdf Yates, J F., & De Oliveira, S P (2016) Culture and decision making Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 136, 106– 118 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.obhdp.2016.05.003 18